• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Manhattan Digest

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

Manhattan Digest
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Sections
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Home / THEATRE / Theater Review: "Hand to God"
THEATRE

Theater Review: "Hand to God"

Margery (Geneva Carr) is on the brink of a breakdown. A recent divorcee, she’s feeling trapped by her responsibilities at her small town Texas fundamental Christian…

RRyan LeedsMarch 17, 20142 min readShare on XShare on FacebookShare by email
Photo Courtesy of Joan Marcus
Photo Courtesy of Joan Marcus

Margery  (Geneva Carr) is on the brink of a breakdown. A recent divorcee, she’s feeling trapped by her responsibilities at her small town Texas  fundamental Christian church. The yearly pageant is nearing and she must produce a sock puppet skit with her trio of uninspired children, one of whom is her son, Jason (Steven Boyer). Jason is a model  mama’s boy, at least until Tyrone materializes.  Tyrone is his hand puppet, who just happens to be the devil. Soon, Tyrone is hell bent on demonizing his fellow puppeteers by leading them all down the primrose path of dalliance. Yes. This is a comedy-and a  wild, outrageously funny one at that.

MCC Theater’s Hand to God expounds upon the old adage “The devil made me do it”. From Tyrone’s opening monologue on the differences between good and evil , it is clear that mischief and mayhem will ensue.  Yet as funny  as it is, it gives us pause to think of our own human behavior and reflect upon the forces which guide us in our day to day living.

Director Moritz Von Stuelpnagel has assembled a magnificent cast here. Carr is wonderful as the volatile , desperate mother whose succumbs to carnal passion.  Michael Oberholtzer is hilarious (and sexy) as Timothy,  the dim bad boy who fulfills Margery’s needs. Sarah Stiles is terrifically on point as Jessica, the nerdy brainiac fed up with the nonsense around her. Marc Kudisch completes the cast as Pastor Greg, whose sympathetic ear for Margery is guided by alterior motives.  While Robert Askin’s play boasts an accomplished cast, it is Steven Boyer’s immaculate performance that audiences will remember. The way he is able to switch between Jason and Tyrone is unbelievable, and his riff on Abbott and Costello’s classic “Who’s on first” sketch is priceless.

Hand to God is far from a trip to your local Sunday school class and is certainly not appropriate for children, but it is a fun, hilarious, and thought-provoking look at what makes us tick.

Hand to God is now playing through March 30th at the Lucille Lortel Theater, 121 Christopher Street. For tickets, visit https://web.ovationtix.com/trs/cal/32215.

ENTERTAINMENTOPINIONREVIEWSTHEATRE
R

About Ryan Leeds

is a freelance writer living in the Hell's Kitchen section of New York City. A proud native of Central Pennsylvania, he holds a degree in Communications from Penn State University. He attends theater frequently and annoys his friends and colleagues by chattering incessantly about his passion for it.

More in THEATRE

See all stories in THEATRE
THEATRE

'Why I Stuck a Flare Up My Arse For England' Ignites the stage with Humor and Heart

Just in time for World Cup mania, Alex Hill has graced the New York stage with the attention-grabbing…

Ryan LeedsJuly 17, 2026

THEATRE

Dickon in Brooklyn-One Night Only!

Theater queens may recall John Cameron Mitchell from his 1991 portrayal of mystical garden boy Dickon in the…

Ryan LeedsJune 26, 2026

THEATRE

Paper Mill Playhouse Reminds Us Why 'West Side Story' is a Masterpiece

With the Tony Awards quickly approaching, it’s interesting timing for Paper Mill Playhouse’s production of West Side Story…

Ryan LeedsJune 5, 2026

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Footer

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

The publication

  • ADVERTISE
  • Legal hub
  • CAREERS
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • Privacy
  • Terms of use

Follow

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Copyright © 2026 · ManhattanDigest.com is run by Fun & Joy, LLC an Ohio company