• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Manhattan Digest

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

Manhattan Digest
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Sections
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Home / THEATRE / Theater Review: "The Religion Thing"
THEATRE

Theater Review: "The Religion Thing"

Rumspringa-the time frame when typically conservative Amish teens are permitted to taste all the debauchery the world can offer- is a punchline used by stand-up comedian…

RRyan LeedsJuly 14, 20142 min readShare on XShare on FacebookShare by email
ReligionThing_MAIN_Final_Web

Rumspringa-the  time frame when typically conservative Amish teens are permitted to taste all the debauchery the world can offer- is a punchline used by  stand-up comedian Glick (Curran Conner) at the start of Renee Calarco’s The  Religion Thing. After taunting and teasing the audience with the running joke,  Glick adopts a more serious tone and observes how, despite their opportunity to permanently rebel , most Amish adolescents return to the fold. In the 90 minutes that follow, we are fortunate enough to witness a similar faith journey of  all four characters in this extremely funny and contemplative dramatic comedy.

Mo (Katherine McLeod) and Brian (Jamie Geiger) are a seemingly succesful couple. She’s Catholic. He’s Jewish. Neither adhere closely to their own religions until Mo’s best friend Patti (Danielle O’Farrell) ,whom she has not seen in quite some time stops by the house with her new husband, Jeff (Andrew W. Smith) . Mo and Brian giggle at the fact that the two newlyweds met at  their evangelical christian mega church. Once a “party girl”, Patti has now shunned her devilish ways and has decided to quit her career as a lawyer, all in pursuit of being the wife and mother she’s destined herself to be. Patti’s drastic life choice doesn’t bode well with Mo--primarily due to her unique of partnership with Jeff. More could be written on this, but why ruin the plot?

As the two-act play unfolds, we gain depth and insight into Calarco’s characters as they struggle to find peace and resolution in  their own individuals faiths. Two scenes-one in which Jeff’s explains his path to eternal salvation- the other, Brian’s imagined dream visit from a Rabbi are endearing, charming, and redemptive.

While it floats like a breezy sitcom, The Religion Thing simultaneously cuts deeper to the core of spirituality with truths that must be explored by each couple. Director Douglas Hall has assembled an excellent cast that handles the material with a fine balance of thoughtfulness and hilarity. The dialogue is crisp, honest, and most importantly, respectful towards the impact that religion (or lack thereof) has on each of our adult lives. Its’ intention is not to sway us towards a particular dogma, but through its‘ clever writing, will grant us the opportunity to question the value we place on our spiritual doctrines.

The Religion Thing, presented by Project Y Theater. Now playing through August 1st, 2014 at the cell (338 W. 23rd Street between 8th and 9th ave.). For tickets and more information visit www.projectytheatre.org

uncategorizedREVIEWSTHEATRE
R

About Ryan Leeds

is a freelance writer living in the Hell's Kitchen section of New York City. A proud native of Central Pennsylvania, he holds a degree in Communications from Penn State University. He attends theater frequently and annoys his friends and colleagues by chattering incessantly about his passion for it.

More in THEATRE

See all stories in THEATRE
THEATRE

'Why I Stuck a Flare Up My Arse For England' Ignites the stage with Humor and Heart

Just in time for World Cup mania, Alex Hill has graced the New York stage with the attention-grabbing…

Ryan LeedsJuly 17, 2026

THEATRE

Dickon in Brooklyn-One Night Only!

Theater queens may recall John Cameron Mitchell from his 1991 portrayal of mystical garden boy Dickon in the…

Ryan LeedsJune 26, 2026

THEATRE

Paper Mill Playhouse Reminds Us Why 'West Side Story' is a Masterpiece

With the Tony Awards quickly approaching, it’s interesting timing for Paper Mill Playhouse’s production of West Side Story…

Ryan LeedsJune 5, 2026

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Footer

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

The publication

  • ADVERTISE
  • Legal hub
  • CAREERS
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • Privacy
  • Terms of use

Follow

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Copyright © 2026 · ManhattanDigest.com is run by Fun & Joy, LLC an Ohio company