• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Manhattan Digest

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

Manhattan Digest
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Sections
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • LGBT
  • OPINION
  • TECHNOLOGY
Home / THEATRE / Answer the Door, for this is 'Company' to Keep
THEATRE

Answer the Door, for this is 'Company' to Keep

It’s been 51 years since composer Stephen Sondheim and book writer George Furth first seduced audiences into the confusion of love with their smash hit musical…

RRyan LeedsDecember 10, 20212 min readShare on XShare on FacebookShare by email
Photo by Matthew Murphy

It’s been 51 years since composer Stephen Sondheim and book writer George Furth first seduced audiences into the confusion of love with their smash hit musical Company.   Now, producers have once again invited these fickle beings into our Broadway home through a fabulous new production directed by Marianne Elliott.

This time, new guests and themes have emerged, thanks largely in part to Elliot’s creativity and Sondheim’s willingness to suppress his own skepticism.

The central character in 1970 was Bobby, an affable 35-year-old cisgender man with friends who incessantly pushed him into a relationship with a woman.  Subsequent revivals (1995 and 2006) followed suit and cast men in the lead.

Phpto by Matthew Murphy

Here, 35 is looming over Bobbie (Katrina Lenk), a cisgender female whose hesitancy to marriage eludes her coupled friends.

Does it work?  Absolutely.

Although some minor alterations have been made, the musical maintains its original integrity. One might suggest that this version is simply another outdated portrayal of a straight woman who must land a man to find true happiness.  Yet Sondheim fans will understand that human emotions and desires far surpass preconceived notions of  gender or age.  In its soul, Company challenges us—whether single, divorced, coupled, or any combination thereof—to be content with the uncertainty of our romantic choices.

Casting directors Cindy Tolan and Nicholas Petrovich have assembled a marvelous ensemble who deliver this piece with endless zeal. Jennifer Simard, who earned a Tony nomination as a gambling addicted nun in the Broadway musical Disaster!  is a true stand-out as Sarah, a diet and fitness obsessed friend to Bobbie.

Matt Doyle and Etai Benson as Jamie and Paul, respectively, also bring a literal halt to the show with their hilarious gay version of “Not Getting Married Today.” Originally Furth created the roles as Amy and Paul, a heterosexual couple. With a fresh spin on the number, it  feels much more inclusive than it ever could have been.

There is so much fine talent here but it’s tough to top the star power of Patti LuPone as Joanne, the caustic, martini swigging friend who delivers a sharp and bitter version of the show’s most well-known song, “The Ladies Who Lunch.” LuPone performed the role in 2018 London's West End where this revival originated.

Set designer Bunny Christie has imagined an envious neon landscape of Manhattan real estate, suggesting that the apartments might be pristine and slick, even if the lives of their inhabitants might lie in doubt and silent suffering.

When composer Sondheim passed away mere weeks ago, tributes, memorials, and honors followed. His stamp in the theater world was indelible. Company reminds us once again of his true genius and deft insight into humanity. It neither scorns nor applauds romance, but rather presents it in all its bliss, disdain, or tribulation--and it emphasizes how delicate and  vulnerable we all all are under our strong bravados.

If only all of life’s company were this good, we’d never want them to leave.

Company is now playing on Broadway at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theater (West 45th between 8th and Broadway) For tickets and information, click here : companymusical.com

ARTSENTERTAINMENTTHEATRE
R

About Ryan Leeds

is a freelance writer living in the Hell's Kitchen section of New York City. A proud native of Central Pennsylvania, he holds a degree in Communications from Penn State University. He attends theater frequently and annoys his friends and colleagues by chattering incessantly about his passion for it.

More in THEATRE

See all stories in THEATRE
THEATRE

'Why I Stuck a Flare Up My Arse For England' Ignites the stage with Humor and Heart

Just in time for World Cup mania, Alex Hill has graced the New York stage with the attention-grabbing…

Ryan LeedsJuly 17, 2026

THEATRE

Dickon in Brooklyn-One Night Only!

Theater queens may recall John Cameron Mitchell from his 1991 portrayal of mystical garden boy Dickon in the…

Ryan LeedsJune 26, 2026

THEATRE

Paper Mill Playhouse Reminds Us Why 'West Side Story' is a Masterpiece

With the Tony Awards quickly approaching, it’s interesting timing for Paper Mill Playhouse’s production of West Side Story…

Ryan LeedsJune 5, 2026

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Footer

All you need to know about Manhattan culture and so much more...

The publication

  • ADVERTISE
  • Legal hub
  • CAREERS
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • Privacy
  • Terms of use

Follow

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Copyright © 2026 · ManhattanDigest.com is run by Fun & Joy, LLC an Ohio company